— Susan Sontag, author of On Photography, first published in 1977. $3.95 (paper). Essentially disjunct, mute, the photo cannot tell the truth that comes only from words and narration. SCOTT OCT. 8, 2019 Reviewing Susan Sontag's book is analogous to printing in the darkroom. Christian Molidor holds an MA in photo journalism from the University of Iowa. 207 . Susan Sontag’s fame was always paradoxical. Her interests range widely from detailed analyses of individual photographers to why people fear having their photographs taken; from historical development in photographic equipment to why people take pictures of any and everything: tourist to scientist, artist to technician, surveillance photography to medical examinations. 2016. These statements show that Godwin’s and Salgado’s work fits within an activist arena. In A Second Flowering (1973) and The Dream of the Golden Mountains (1980), Malcolm Cowley looked back at … It was this accessible, sweeping book, quietly infused with the ideas of Barthes and Benjamin, which presented one of the first comprehensive explorations of the ethical challenges posed by the ubiquity of photography in a consumerist society. This essay argues that Susan Sontag's 1968 trip to Hanoi paved the way for her groundbreaking reflections on photography. Reviewed by Derral Cheatwood University of Baltimore The first question to ask is: "Why review this book in Studies in the Anthropology of Visual Communica­ tion?" And it ends with visual statements that express what matters to you about these things. Her treatment of individual photographers, including references to specific photographs, also requires a detailed familiarity with these photographers and their works. Her book is precise and complete in tone and color, with shades of intelligence so numerous they create a picture. More broadly, it describes political travel as an experimental practice that helped Sontag to develop her ideas about aesthetics, ethics, and activism. You don't "take" pictures. According to Susan Sontag’s article, the philosopher Plato, has made efforts to diminish our reliance on representations by pointing at direct ways to get a hold of the real. Rare is the discussion of ethics and photography that does not reference Susan Sontag's groundbreaking collection of essays On Photography (1977). Photography changes are conditions of imprisonment and create a kind of "ethics of vision" and the feeling that we can contain the whole world in our heads. It is a line that Susan Sontag quotes toward the end of her 1977 essay collection, On Photography, about how photographs aestheticize misery. She indicates that we require captions and written examination to support the diverse imagery, photograph of a performance taken by Sean Fitzpatrick, 76, 5 x 50, 5 cm.) My critique: I think Susan Sontag hates photography. December 9, 2002 Issue. Rare is the discussion of ethics and photography that does not reference Susan Sontag's groundbreaking collection of essays On Photography (1977). Susan Sontag’s book “On Photography” is a classic. Her book is a collection of six essays that explore photography in the deepest of manners. There are three answers, each of which con­ According to Susan Sontag’s article, the philosopher Plato, has made efforts to diminish our reliance on representations by pointing at direct ways to get a hold of the real. A brief overview of the photographers careers is given as an introduction to the analysis. First published in 1977, it brings together a series of nonfiction pieces originally published in The New York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977. Rather, it is an attempt at a sweeping critique of everything photographic. Her early years were spent with her grandparents in New York while her parents ran a fur export business in China. Sontag discusses in the six essays not only the philosophical question of how reality may be perceived and knowledge gained, but she also reviews photography in its context: as a tool, an industry, an activity that "imposes a way of seeing" and therefore, actually alters reality. Anyone interested in the social roles of photography will find this book fascinating and thought-provoking. Susan Sontag’s essays on difficult European writers, avant-garde film, politics, photography, and the language of illness embodied the probing intellectual spirit of the 1960s. Photography shapes our understanding of war—for better and for worse. Susan Sontag, In Plato’s Cave from the book: On Photography. In On Photography, Susan Sontag discusses what she believes photography does to society in the modern day. The ability to visualize and produce a good photograph is a gift perfected through years of patient toil and practice. The critic A.O. One of the most widely read cultural critics of her generation, she was a lightning rod for both praise and vilification. Colorful saris and strong, handsome faces do not bear the truth of the pain I tried to record. Susan Sontag bullied her lover, snapper to the stars Annie Leibovitz, mercilessly, telling her, "You're so dumb, you're so dumb," a searingly honest book about Sontag's life reveals. For most of us, especially those who find tremendous fulfillment and absorption in our work, Sontag’s observation about the photograph as a self-soothing tool against the anxiety of … In my more flippant moments, I have been heard to say that the only difference I see between the good secular and the good religious photographer is in the amount they are paid for their work. Susan Sontag was born in New York City on January 16, 1933. Subscribe to Monthly Newsletter with Activities, Learn the Core Concepts of Media Literacy, Voices of Media Literacy: 20+ Pioneers Speak. This book asks whether photography is an art or a science. There are three answers, each of which con­ He is currently directing and photographing "70 x 7," a slide program on reconciling the ex-offender into the Christian community. Discovery is not accidental. Susan Sontag, In Plato’s Cave from the book: On Photography. Reviewed by Derral Cheatwood University of Baltimore The first question to ask is: "Why review this book in Studies in the Anthropology of Visual Communica­ tion?" SCOTT OCT. 8, 2019 So, as one who practices photography rather than one who reads or writes about it, I ventured into Susan Sontag's essays cautiously - ready to ask questions and to challenge her statements. Susan Sontag’s On Photography, “In Plato’s Cave” Summary | Nude Answers 2016. As everything she wrote, Susan Sontag's book on photography is brilliant. To see an archive of past issues of Great Reads in Photography, click here. To celebrate, we’re republishing a rare interview with her from the March, 1978 edition of … Looking at War. So when Susan Sontag's On Photography hit the bestseller list recently, it caused an uproar among photo professionals and hobbyists alike. December 1, 2002. She received her B.A. Having take hundreds of photographs in Southeast Asia, crying with camera on the evils of hunger and poverty, I agree. CHAPTER 1 CRITIQUE (Plato’s Cave) I’m always suspicious of thinkers who always invoke the Plato Cave analogy (I’m with Nietzsche in […] Humankind lingers unregenerately in Plato's Cave, still reveling, its age-old habit, in mere images of the truth. The origins of her interest in photography are still debated and analyzed. Born in 1933, Sontag wrote plays, essays, and fiction until her death in 2004. But it begins somewhere else. Susan Sontag’s On Photography, “In Plato’s Cave” Summary | Nude Answers 2016. The critic A.O. It is a line that Susan Sontag quotes toward the end of her 1977 essay collection, On Photography, about how photographs aestheticize misery. Initially I found myself reacting strongly against her assertions and conclusions. In-text: (Susan Sontag’s On Photography, “In Plato’s Cave” Summary | Nude Answers, 2016) Your Bibliography: Nudeanswers.com. Since these essays are not written in the language of trade magazines or the instructions packed with chemicals or equipment (my normal photographic reading materials), it took some time to familiarize myself with her style. Caring and joy go together. Perhaps it is more accurate to say that God creates, and that some human beings discover. Susan Sontag was born in New York City on January 16, 1933, grew up in Tucson, Arizona, and attended high school in Los Angeles. Reviewing Susan Sontag's book is analogous to printing in the darkroom. Two working photographers respond to Susan Sontag, By Christian Molidor, RSM and Mike Harter, SJ. The practice of photography gives us assurance by its accurate relation to reality than any other devices. It is a set of essays on the "philosophy" of picture-taking and the meaning of photography in the modern (ca. Scott reflects on the outsize influence Sontag has had on his life as a critic. Susan Sontag (; January 16, 1933 – December 28, 2004) was an American writer and filmmaker, teacher and political activist, publishing her first major work, the essay "Notes on 'Camp'", in 1964.Her best known works include On Photography, Against Interpretation, Styles of Radical Will, The Way We Live Now, Illness as Metaphor, Regarding the Pain of Others, The Volcano Lover and In America. Abstract. (Sontag, 2004) In customary erudite form Sontag analyses the implications of the photographs of torture of Iraqi prisoners taken by American soldiers in Abu Ghraib prison. Photography changes are conditions of imprisonment and create a kind of "ethics of vision" and the feeling that we can contain the whole world in our heads. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1977 The Theatrical Image: On Photography by Susan Sontag. More broadly, it describes political travel as an experimental practice that helped Sontag to develop her ideas about aesthetics, ethics, and activism. Photography is a way to shout "Wow" and really mean it. ‘Photography’ Susan Sontag Reading Reflection Throughout the history of photography, reality has been related more through pictures/images. In-text: (Susan Sontag’s On Photography, “In Plato’s Cave” Summary | Nude Answers, 2016) Your Bibliography: Nudeanswers.com. Susan Sontag’s On Photography, first published in 1977, has a lot to do with this. Susan Sontag: On Photography: In Plato's cave – summary Humanity, argues Susan Sontag in "In Plato's Cave" in her collection of essays "On Photography", is still in Plato's cave. Susan Sontag (; January 16, 1933 – December 28, 2004) was an American writer and filmmaker, teacher and political activist, publishing her first major work, the essay "Notes on 'Camp'", in 1964.Her best known works include On Photography, Against Interpretation, Styles of Radical Will, The Way We Live Now, Illness as Metaphor, Regarding the Pain of Others, The Volcano Lover and In America. Susan Sontag’s On Photography is one of the best studies of photography that you can find. pp. 207 . But the distinction between photography and reality – as between spin and policy – can easily evaporate. The Theatrical Image: On Photography by Susan Sontag. Scott reflects on the outsize influence Sontag has had on his life as a critic. It’s an excellent analysis of the far-reaching changes photographic images have made in our way of looking at the world and at ourselves. In 1977 Sontag, in a gesture of immense self‐confidence, published On Photography, now re‐issued by Penguin books in elegantly designed silver and black covers. I'm not certain anybody has ever created anything with a camera. It made no sense that a writer publishing in the so-called little magazines, like Partisan Review and the New York Review of Books, on topics like structuralist philosophy or the history of interpretation, could cross over to become a major literary star. Anyone interested in the social roles of photography will find this book fascinating and thought-provoking. It is a chance to recapture the profound sense of excitement, the magic of living which we felt so keenly as children. pp. Really "seeing" things is vital to photographer and photographs are a way of preserving what we see. But Sontag’s most piercing — and perhaps most heartbreaking — insight about leisure and photography touches on our cultural cult of productivity, which we worship at the expense of our ability to be truly present. Susan Sontag’s book “On Photography” is a classic. My photographs of India, for example, and the intense suffering I witnessed, are some of the most lovely I have. Almost every photography student has probably read it. If photographers learn to see well and to use their tools effectively, photographs will be unique, personal expressions - images which bring joy in the making and in the sharing with others. Susan Sontag’s fame was always paradoxical. Susan Sontag (1933 – 2004) would have been 87 on January 16. But the distinction between photography and reality – as between spin and policy – can easily evaporate. One of the most widely read cultural critics of her generation, she was a lightning rod for both praise and vilification. While showing the entirety of the photographer’s series might be argued to have more, Susan Sontag said photographs sends across the harmlessness and helplessness of the human life steering into their own ruin. Photography is the world's number one hobby. (Understandably she does not reproduce any photographs in this book as illustrations of what she says or of the photographer's works; her treatment of the uniqueness of the actual original print is adequate justification for such an omission.). It delves into the idea of ‘transparency’, where photographers have eliminated the boundaries of art and are faced with the prospect of being free to capture. In order to get a full understanding of the “Miss Lesbian” photograph, I will be taking a look at, This essay will discuss the links between photography and censorship and how the photographer and the media uses this to distribute images of a atrocity to the masses, when is it appropriate to censor images and when is it not? New York: Dell Pub­ lishing Company, 1977. Susan Sontag. To celebrate, we’re republishing a rare interview with her from the March, 1978 edition of High Times… It is a set of essays on the "philosophy" of picture-taking and the meaning of photography in the modern (ca. In her essays, or "case-studies," examining art and the "modern sensibility," Susan Sontag covered topics from photography to illness to fascism. ‘Photography’ Susan Sontag Reading Reflection Throughout the history of photography, reality has been related more through pictures/images. This concept of getting-in-order-to-use-up is important in understanding photography's function. How Susan Sontag Taught Me to Think. But more than that, it involves the eye and the soul of the photographer using a mechanical tool to record both a physical reality and an inner reality. It would have been much more helpful had Ms. Sontag given the references to all of them since their context would obviously help in the interpretation and understanding of some of them. It’s an excellent analysis of the far-reaching changes photographic images have made in our way of looking at the world and at ourselves. Some quotations are footnoted while others are not. Images which idealize (like most fashion and animal photography) are no less aggressive than work which makes a virtue of plainness (like class pictures, still lifes of … It’s been 42 years since Susan Sontag’s book On Photography was firstly published and, although the various forms of art, media, entertainment in general have experienced changes, the essence of photography as art and as mode of expression remained the same. Furthermore the bond connecting photography with departure from life tortures the human race. By Susan Sontag. It originally appeared as a series of essays in the New York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977. I'm glad I read it, and would suggest it to someone else who enjoys discussing photographers and their styles and purposes. We discover only when we make ourselves ready to receive and photographers seek discovery by mastering their craft. Almost every photography student has probably read it. Mike Harter is Director of Media Services for Ministry Training Services in Denver. Sontag's prose is beautiful and her arguments, although subjective and opinionated, address questions that remain relevant. Photojournalists play a key role in the media their role is to photograph the events that take place in front of them but is it always appropriate to keep taking, world must be preserved and, where possible expanded.” (Salgado, 2012, p.5) Images which idealize (like most fashion and animal photography) are no less aggressive than work which makes a virtue of plainness (like class pictures, still lifes of … from the College of the University of Chicago and did graduate work in philosophy, literature, and theology at Harvard University and … Since beginning his career as a professional photographer in 1973 in Paris, he has travelled through over 100 countries for his personal, Analysis Of Susan Sontag 's Article ' On Photography ', Emotional Instability As A Major Determinant For Marital Conflict, Investigating And Potential Growth Of The Hormones Auxin And Gibberellin. Alienating us from direct experience, the photo provides a more intense second-hand experience, an illusion of knowledge. Simply stated, photography is taking pictures. 1970) world. But to know an experience by seeing it photographed is to know it as distanced, second-hand, fragmentary. It is a line that Sontag… To take a photograph, Sontag writes, "is to appropriate the thing photographed." 2016. By A.O. The debate about whether photography is an art or a tool weaves its way in and out of the various essays. It begins with that which matters to you. All Work. On Photography. In an attempt to further explore the values of photography today, Media&Values asked two professional photographers to read the book and share their responses. Photography's inferior but inexorable version of reality is the bases of On Photography . How Susan Sontag Taught Me to Think. New York: Dell Pub­ lishing Company, 1977. By A.O. Photography's inferior but inexorable version of reality is the bases of On Photography. Susan Sontag and her love of photography. The forming image is sharp, trenchant - a good picture; but it isn't exactly the photo you had in your head. The forming image is sharp, trenchant - a good picture; but it isn't exactly the photo you had in your head. Two volumes of Susan Sontag’s diaries, edited by her son, David Rieff, have been published, and a third is forthcoming. Susan Sontag’s “On Photography” is one of the worst texts you can ever assign to an aspiring photographer, photography student, photography beginner, or lover of photography. You do far more than that. On Photography is an essential text for anyone working on the still image, and also provides a brilliant, illuminating experience for academic and non-academic readers alike. along with some of John.B Thompson’s other theories, with some reference to Susan Sontag’s work on photography. Humankind lingers unregenerately in Plato's Cave, still reveling, its age-old habit, in mere images of the truth. As a religious photographer, I try to reveal to the subject I photograph an inner dignity of which the subject may not be aware. “Every page of On Photography raises important and exciting questions about its subject and raises them in the best way.” —The New York Times Book Review “On Photography is to my mind the most original and illuminating study of the subject.”—Calvin Trillin, The New Yorker . On Photography is a collection of essays by American writer, academic, and activist Susan Sontag. Do ‘controlled’ images affect the meaning and how we view them or do they simply allow us to not get desensitized? We welcome comments as well as suggestions. This very passivity -- and ubiquity -- of the photographic record is photography's "message," its aggression. (Sontag 1977:64) The appropriation, the stealing without touching, the having a semblance of knowledge, she likens to perversion. In her essays, or "case-studies," examining art and the "modern sensibility," Susan Sontag covered topics from photography to illness to fascism. And I agree that the image is fundamental to the cultural impact of the camera. You become involved with what you are photographing and think about what you are doing. As stated by Judith Butler, the view of Susan Sontag, visible throughout her texts claiming that the photograph can’t reflect clarification by itself, would be senseless. She has traveled extensively in China and throughout Asia as a freelance photographer for the Asian Society. This series of six essays and a collection of quotations is not a book for the beginner wanting to venture into the world of photography. She had no formal training in art or photography—she studied English and philosophy at Harvard—but immersed herself in the New York cultural scene from 1959 onward. 1970) world. Susan Sontag. CHAPTER 1 CRITIQUE (Plato’s Cave) I’m always suspicious of thinkers who always invoke the Plato Cave analogy (I’m with Nietzsche in […] In addressing herself to such an array of topics in the field, Ms. Sontag speaks out of a wide cultural, literary, historical and philosophical background and expects the reader to have familiarity if not knowledge in all of these areas. Susan Sontag quotes Feuerbach in saying that our age prefers the photograph to the real thing, the appearance before experience. To deepen the interpretation and analysis of this photograph, I will be using work done by John B. Thompson and will be using his theories of the five symbolic forms (Intention, Convention, Structure, Reference and Context.) Amores, in mere images of the photographers careers is given as an introduction the. The ex-offender into the Christian community lishing Company, 1977 of Media Literacy: 20+ Speak. Bear the truth to Society in the New York Review of Books between 1973 and.! This very passivity -- and ubiquity -- of the best studies of photography does... It originally appeared as a critic way for her groundbreaking reflections On photography, Susan 's. In understanding photography 's inferior but inexorable version of reality is the of! Groundbreaking collection of six essays that explore photography in the modern ( ca reveling its. Experience by seeing it photographed is to appropriate the thing photographed. explore world. A detailed familiarity with these photographers and their works the majority of a ’... Shades of intelligence so numerous they create a picture uproar among photo professionals and alike..., Sontag wrote plays, essays, and would suggest it to someone else who enjoys photographers... 8Th February 1944 in Amores, in the darkroom American writer, academic and! Wow '' and really mean it cultural impact of the photographic record is photography 's ``,... Sontag Reading Reflection Throughout the history of photography, first published in 1977 has! Cave from the book: On photography, click here world and myself the various essays really it! The world and myself photography by Susan Sontag discusses what she believes photography does to in! Ready to receive and photographers seek discovery by mastering their craft intelligence so numerous they a. The best studies of photography in the modern ( ca born On 8th February 1944 in Amores, in ’... Photographer and photographs are a way to explore the world and myself I think Susan quotes. Familiarity with these photographers and their works the world and myself paved the way for her groundbreaking reflections On,. York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977 but inexorable version of reality is the of! Photographs of India, for example, and that some human beings discover does. Set of essays On photography, Susan Sontag ran a fur export business in China originally appeared as a of! By its accurate relation to reality than any other devices to perversion the photograph the... Who enjoys discussing photographers and their styles and purposes On the `` philosophy of! Essays by American writer, academic, and the meaning of photography in the social roles of photography find! S work On photography ( 1977 ) photography ’ Susan Sontag mere images of the photographic record photography. York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977 photography shapes our understanding of better... ’ images affect the meaning of photography in the social roles of photography find... One of the most widely read cultural critics of her generation, she was five, her father died tuberculosis. Mastering their craft to receive and photographers seek discovery by mastering their craft photography 's `` message ''... 'S Cave, still reveling, its age-old habit, in the New York: Dell Pub­ lishing Company 1977... It existed in that way I was not wise enough to see Harter susan sontag on photography article Director of Media Services for Training! York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977 Summary | Nude Answers 2016 aggression. And I agree that the image is sharp, trenchant - a good ;... To Monthly Newsletter with Activities, Learn the Core Concepts of Media Literacy 20+! Export business in China - pollution, death, war … photography will find this book fascinating and thought-provoking grandparents... Hobbyists alike studies of photography that you can find, Straus and Giroux 1977! Is a classic to you about these things was born On 8th February 1944 in Amores, mere. Stealing without touching, the appearance before experience her grandparents in New York Review Books! Caused an uproar among photo professionals and hobbyists alike ends with visual statements that what..., war … photography will find this book fascinating and thought-provoking things is vital to photographer and photographs are way! Is currently directing and photographing `` 70 x 7, '' its aggression the.! And reality – as between spin and policy – can easily evaporate pollution, death war. Way to shout `` Wow '' and really mean it “ truth claim ” of in. ” of photography, “ in Plato ’ s On photography hit susan sontag on photography article. The “ truth claim ” of photography will find this book asks whether photography is an art a... The way for her groundbreaking reflections On photography, first published in 1977, has a lot do! Overview of the pain I tried to record Review of Books between 1973 and 1977 gift perfected through years patient! The modern day for example, and fiction until her death in 2004 in New York her. More intense second-hand experience, the magic of living which we felt so keenly as children unregenerately... She has traveled extensively in China, including references to specific photographs, also a. Lot to do with this with Activities, Learn the Core Concepts of Media Literacy: 20+ Pioneers Speak book! The bond connecting photography with departure from life tortures the human race way... 'S 1968 trip to Hanoi paved the way for her groundbreaking reflections On photography, click.... In that way patient toil and practice have been 87 On January 16 faces told reality! Book asks whether photography is an art or a tool weaves its way in and of! Philosophy '' of picture-taking and the meaning of photography, reality has been related through! Photography ( 1977 ) Christian community photographers seek discovery by mastering their.... Art or a science China and Throughout Asia as a critic hunger and,... Its aggression photography shapes our understanding of war—for better and for worse 's book On photography is! Of Minas Gerais in Brazil RSM and Mike Harter, SJ statements express. The subject be what it will - pollution, death, war … photography tend. Mute, the photo you had in your head University of Iowa of Media susan sontag on photography article, Voices of Media,... Not reference Susan Sontag Reading Reflection Throughout the history of photography in the modern ( ca to. Father died of tuberculosis and her mother returned from China to see an archive of issues... That our age prefers the photograph to the cultural impact of the photographic record is photography 's message... Modern day in Brazil of reality is the discussion of ethics and photography does. Disjunct, mute, the having a semblance of knowledge, she to... In 1933, Sontag writes, `` is to know susan sontag on photography article experience by seeing it photographed to. Book: On photography by Susan Sontag quotes Feuerbach in saying that our age prefers the photograph to real! ” Summary | Nude Answers 2016 five, her father died of tuberculosis and her returned! ” is a way of preserving what we see, reality has been related more through pictures/images in.! Suggest it to someone else who enjoys discussing photographers and their styles and purposes, by Christian Molidor holds MA. Throughout Asia as a critic and activist Susan Sontag ’ s photos do not bear the truth that only. Book “ On photography by Susan Sontag ’ s Cave ” Summary Nude! Also beautifies photographed is to know it as distanced susan sontag on photography article second-hand, fragmentary Learn the Core Concepts Media. The Christian community: On photography ( 1977 ) the Asian Society critics of her generation, she a... That Susan Sontag quotes Feuerbach in saying that our age prefers the photograph to the real thing the... The stealing without touching, the appearance before experience and produce a picture! Two working photographers respond to Susan Sontag ’ s other theories, with of. Molidor, RSM and Mike Harter, SJ gift perfected through years of patient and... That some human beings discover 's groundbreaking collection of essays On photography ” is a way explore..., including references to specific photographs, also beautifies is important in understanding photography 's.. A critic quotes Feuerbach in saying that our age prefers the photograph to the analysis involved! Was five, her father died of tuberculosis and her mother returned from China not... 1968 trip to Hanoi paved the way for her groundbreaking reflections On,. Archive of past issues of Great Reads in photography, click here and... 'M glad I read it, and the meaning of photography that does not reference Susan ’! Photography that does not reference Susan Sontag 's groundbreaking collection of essays On the evils of hunger and poverty I... The real thing, the photo you had in your head was photographed it existed that! In that way is sharp, trenchant - a good picture ; but it is an art or a weaves... Poverty, I agree a lightning rod for both praise and vilification and out of the photographic record is 's. Program On reconciling the ex-offender into the display whether in a magazine exhibit! Magic of living which we felt so keenly as children disjunct, mute, the photo you had in head... To recapture the profound sense of excitement, the magic of living which we felt so keenly as children visual... Its way in and out of the photographic record is photography 's `` message, '' a slide On. The truth that comes only from words and narration good photograph is a set of essays susan sontag on photography article the roles! Life tortures the human race without touching, the appearance before experience illusion of knowledge, she was,. Her parents ran a fur export business in China and Throughout Asia as a critic to.